Toni Valencia
Oct 24, 2017

Why I think different religions are not all that different.

2 comments

Edited: Oct 24, 2017

I was born and raised in the sunny islands of the Philippines where the majority of the population are Roman Catholics. My foundation of values and beliefs were built from my religion. One often repeated value is to "love thy neighbour as you love yourself."

 

Talking to two of my friends, one who is Muslim and the other who is Jewish, I found that our religious texts connected to one another. More specifically, Judaism's religious text shares similar stories to the Old Testament in the Christian Bible. Christian text then continues the stories of the New Testament, which is then continued in the Islam's religious text known as the Qur'an. Since our stories are similar and are a continuation of one another, we investigated further and found that our values and beliefs are similar as well, just practised in different manners.

 

Living in Japan where Shintoism is the main religion, the same core values to love and help one another is evident. Even with some of the friends who are not religious, they still learn the importance of charitable actions and helping the community.

 

I found that religion is more of a guiding path to building a foundation of core values and beliefs. While different religions have different practices, I think all religions still embed the similar core values of kindness, integrity, and spreading peace and love to one another. Due to this, I still continue to question why some conflicts in our present day are based on religion. To be fair, the practices are still different and that may be the source of conflict. Also, I must admit that I am not exposed to every religion on this planet, neither am I well-versed in many, but at least the ones I know of so far are quite similar in values in my opinion.

 

But hey, that's just my two cents.

 

What are your thoughts on religions and values? Do you think that each religion is different or similar?

 

Feel free to reach out to me if you have any questions or if you would like to engage in a discussion :)

ewennberg19
Nov 5, 2017

I think the similarities between Christianity, Judaism, and Islam are fascinating, as those three are extremely similar in their texts but often are the most engaged in religious conflict. I also think it's interesting how people refer to the Muslim god as "Allah", who is the same "God" that Christians and Jews worship to. This seems to me like a tactic to make Islam seem more different from Christianity/Judaism than it actually is, (a.k.a. "other"-ing Islam), as in the English language, no one refers to the Jewish God as "Adonai"!

Felicity Wong
Jul 25, 2018

As a religious Christian, I think I would agree that most religions often preach about the same values, i.e. practicing goodness, charity, etc. Many people often use their religion and their faith in order to guide their own moral compass, and that’s something to be respected and celebrated. Christianity, Judaism, and Islam share a lot of the same cultural roots that date back thousands of years ago. However, I think there are some key characteristics about each religion that are often overlooked -- these nuances go beyond dictating what is moral and immoral. For example, Lutheranism, the Christian denomination that I am a part of, states that Jesus was sent as a gift from God to save a sinful humanity; good works are only an act of gratitude towards God. That theology (justification by grace through faith) would not apply to Judaism, Islam, or even Catholicism. The way and intention that you view a moral act I think differs from religion to religion if that makes any sense, and is often one of many distinguishing factors between them. Even beyond morality, there are parts of the Gospel and the catechism that make my faith unique from others.

 

With regards to your question about conflicts as a result of religion -- I think a lot of the wars either occur because of political tensions or because of extremist sects within a religion (cf. the Middle East), which may not necessarily espouse the beliefs of most people who identify with that religion.

New Posts
  • Aung Myo Htun ( Kelly)
    Dec 31, 2017

    Buddhism has no God. We do not worship and believe any gods or God. People outside of Buddhism often think that Buddhists worship the Buddha. However, the Buddha (Siddhartha Gautama) never claimed to be divine, but he is viewed by Buddhists as having attained what they are also striving to attain, which is spiritual enlightenment and, with it, freedom from the continuous cycle of life and death. That is why the ultimate goal of Buddhism is “Nirvana” (kind of peace in heaven). As for me, I don’t believe any gods or God except our Buddha who is a pioneer of the natural basic rules that is how to live in life, how to communicate with people, what is honest, how to remind ourselves every day. Let me know any comment or discussion. Aung Myo Htun ( Kelly) Myanmar
  • Lucy
    Nov 9, 2017

    Interesting Article about the declining role of religion in the Middle East by the Economist https://www.economist.com/news/middle-east-and-africa/21730899-they-are-consolidating-their-own-power-process-despots-are-pushing
  • Valerie Wu
    Nov 13, 2017

    I come from a predominantly non-religious family, but decided I wanted to attend a private all-girls school for high school in eighth grade. I ended up attending a Catholic all-girls school about thirty minutes away. At the start, religion was the most difficult class for me--all of our essays had to begin with "as a Christian" even though some members of the class weren't Christian. When I began producing our school's weekly news segment, I was told that we had to focus on Pope Francis more. Currently, liturgical masses are required as part of the curriculumn, and not attending can lead to a detention. It's been hard trying to adapt to this newfound environment. Ultimately, though, it was my choice and I've learned to understand religion not as a "selective group"--which is how I viewed it before high school, but as a way of understanding the world. Yet I do acknowledge that being forced to start essays with "as a Christian" for a grade, or even participating in certain religious activites that go against one's own beliefs, may not be the most considerate way(s) of respecting our religious divides. How do you think (religious) minority students should act in this situation? What would be your advice to those who feel that ther own beliefs are not being understood?